This is a reply to your open letter “Open Letter to PixInsight Users: Your Choice”. It was originally posted to the PixInsight For Beginners Facebook group, from where it was removed by the admins for not being “on topic”.
Please allow me to start by stating a few things up front:
I have enormous respect for you and the team for what you’ve accomplished with PixInsight. The software isn’t some small thing, it’s a feat of engineering. I’ve been a user for a short 6 years and the continuous progress and improvements you all keep making show how much love you have for this field.
I also completely agree that no-one should be stealing your hard work. Out-right copying your features just because AI makes it easier to do is not OK. I agree, that’s straight up theft.
I also don’t doubt the struggles you’ve gone through over time and how protective you feel about the product you’ve made. In your shoes, I would feel the same too.
With that said, I do believe you’ve missing some important elements here. I don’t know if you’ve missed them or chosen to dismiss them. In the end the outcome is the same:
You haven’t just built a product or a platform, you’ve built a community. The people who use your software and the people who contribute to it through process modules or scripts are invested in this too. We’ve come to expect a level of openness that existed before because it made the platform better for us, the users.
You’ve said several times you feel hurt because people are trying to “destroy” PixInsight by replacing or competing with its core functionality.
I accept it may feel like that to you, but nothing could be further from reality. Has anyone ever said “Let’s make these modules for PixInsight because it’ll destroy the platform!”
No, never. It’s always been the opposite.
People have sought to enhance or complement what’s there, or provide a slightly different way to do things.
I still remember when you pulled NormaliseScaleGradient and made those comments about processes “competing” with built-in functionality. It wasn’t competition, it was an addition as so many other things have been.
We’ve come to expect a more open platform than you’re willing to provide because that’s what we thought we had for such a long time. And now we feel like we’ve been part of a bait-and-switch, the same kind so many big software companies do to their users when they get to a certain size.
People are upset and pushing back in the ways they can.
And it makes matters worse when, instead of feeling heard, your users feel ignored or treated like misbehaving children who need to be quiet and do as they’re told.
I love the product you’ve made. There’s nothing even remotely close or as good. And no matter how much someone uses AI to try and duplicate it, PixInsight will endure not just because of the software but also because of the community.
That is, as long as the community feels welcomed by you.
Right now I would say a lot of people don’t, and even worse it feels like you’re doubling down and saying you don’t care about that.
I will keep using and supporting the software because I believe it’s the best one out there.
I will keep being a part of this community as long as the community will have me.
But Sir, I implore you to look at your own actions in this too and see how they’re stoking the fire. It’s creating unnecessary friction because you think everyone is out to get you, when all we want to do is enjoy astrophotography.
Your kindly
Avleen Vig

Leave a Reply